Write a 3-4 page essay in which you analyze and evaluate Bill Maherâ€™s argument in the film Religulous. You should also provide your own developed opinion about the issue of controversy in this film.
Some things to consider:
- How is Maherâ€™s argument structured? Briefly describe and evaluate the way Maherâ€™s argument is put together. You should clearly state his conclusion/thesis and the central premises of his position, along with his key supporting evidence.
- Does the argument contain any fallacies? If so, discuss which ones, supported by specific references to the film.
- Were any parts of Maherâ€™s argument particularly convincing or persuasive? If so, refer to them specifically. Were any parts particularly ineffective or even offensive? Againâ€¦be as specific as you can!
- Lastly, do you agree with Maherâ€™s position on this issue? If so, why? If not, why not? Clearly state your own view on the issue, supporting your position with specific reasons (premises) and any examples from your own experience, research, your observation of others, or any of your reading/viewing, including the film Religulous itself.
(About half your paper should analyze/evaluate Maherâ€™s argument; the other half should explore your personal views on this issue.)